Leader Silence on Coop Merger Stampede

One of life’s  defining moments is being on the losing side.  It could be in a critical game, or competing in a local or national election, or the ultimate experience of war.

But when that happens there is an even greater loss.  That is  when one  realizes they were on the wrong side of events  in the first place.  Consider defeated political candidates who change parties or veterans who turn against the wars  in which they participated.

The Cooperative Merger Feeding Frenzy

The realization that one was on the wrong side from the beginning reminded me of the silent consent of industry leaders in the midst of the movement’s merger rampage.

Several public commentators and I have publicly challenged the nonsensical proposal for SAFE to turn over the fortunes of its 245,000 member owners to Boeing Employees Credit Union.  An action members did not seek, was never discussed with them and was executed in secret by a definitive merger agreement signed by both boards.

I received an email asking why the only industry leaders who openly discussed these chartering life or death decisions by hundreds of long-serving healthy credit union boards was challenged only by retired CEOs.    Here is an except of the writer’s concern:

An entire next generation (employees and leaders) wants to take action on this issue but can’t. They can’t even comment or like on LinkedIn without putting their jobs and careers at risk. 
This is the case from league staff and contractors to credit union staff.
That is why it’s almost entirely retired, or close to retiring, CEOs who are the public voice.
Is there a way to fund or create a group/website and have a channel for anonymous whistleblowing?

On The Losing Side

As the movement collapses upon itself led by the dark stars of merger advocates and gravitational pull of money, will  credit unions cohere into an  inert remnant of America’s financial universe?  Like the  the  S&L industry?

It would seem a question at the top of the agenda for those who want to lead the movement into a worthwhile, sustainable future.  Why the silence?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *