A Fee that Credit Unions Should Review for Appropriateness

Increasing attention is being given to all financial institution’s overdraft/courtesy-pay/nsf fee structures.   An excellent summary of many of the issues is in this article from CUSO magazine.

After the reassessments of these fees, there is another one that credit unions may want to proactively review.

The Unclaimed Property/Inactive Account Fee

A member recently told the story about learning of this fee the hard way.   She had been a loyal credit union member for over two decades and had left a small balance of $500 in case a family member needed to borrow.

The regular savings account paid interest of .05%, offered only online statements and had no activity for over two years.  When checking her 2021 yearend balance online she discovered that the amount had fallen by 20%.

The explanation: a $3 per month inactive account fee was being assessed.  She knew nothing about the fee or how long it had been in place.  In essence she felt the credit union had effectively free use of her money and was charging her on top of that!

When contacted, the credit union explained the fee and offered to refund the money for the last two years, which was as far back as their system would go.

Credit Union’s Responsibility for Inactive Accounts

When Ed, Bucky and I went to NCUA in 1981, I can remember credit unions approaching the agency about charging inactive account fees, which in essence was the step prior to forwarding these accounts to the states as unclaimed property.

In Illinois the Department of Financial Institutions was responsible for administering the unclaimed property act and ensuring funds were properly reported, returned to the state after five years of inactivity so the owners’ names could be publicly listed to  reclaim their funds.

My colleagues believed charging a fee during this inactive period was counter to both the spirit of the act and for a cooperative financial institution.

Credit unions claimed  the accounts were costing them money: maintaining the account, mailing monthly or quarterly statements and plus interest.  Even as they tried to reactivate them, they wanted to be reimbursed for the operational “costs” of the accounts.

For others, the not so hidden motive was to fee the account to $0, especially smaller balances,  close out the member, and not worry about reporting it as unclaimed property.

Others asserted that the fee was in fact an incentive for members to reactivate their accounts.

Inactive accounts come in all flavors:  parents opening accounts for their children, now long gone; accounts left when members move out of the area; the account opened for an indirect loan member, etc.

The common characteristics are there is no member-initiated account activity, the relationship is static, and there is high probability the owner is unaware of any fees being charged.   Therefore it is an easy fee to assess as it is mostly invisible to the account holder.

Other Credit Union Examples

One CEO I talked with said they charge $3 a month on about 500 accounts generating $1,500 in revenue.   At any point in time about 40% of the accounts will be sent to the state.

Another CEO said the credit union charges $10 per quarter.   In both cases the fee had not been evaluated for decades.

Both recognized that in an era of virtual accounts, minimal interest on savings and near zero marginal operating costs, the credit union should focus on contacting members, not seeing the issue as a revenue item.

I would urge credit unions to look at their current inactive account policy and fees.   It may not be as consequential as overdrafts, but if a class action attorney situation arrives, just looking up the years of records, charges and potential refunds, would seem to suggest any income is not worth the potential cost.

Also don’t forget abandoned safety deposit boxes must also be reported as unclaimed after the statutory period of inactivity.

NCUA’s Unclaimed Policy

Just as a footnote, NCUA also acquires unclaimed insured share accounts when liquidating credit unions.

It is interesting to note that the agency’s policy is contrary to the legal practice required of credit unions.

As stated on the website, if NCUA cannot locate the party after 18 months, it converts them to “uninsured” and retains the balances for use by the insurance fund.

Invariably, some items may remain unclaimed. Some checks are never cashed; or the credit union’s address information was incomplete. There are also cases when we don’t have a recent address and are unable to get a forwarding address from the post office.

Share accounts claimed within the 18-month insurance period are paid at their full-insured amount. At the expiration of the 18-month insurance period, shares that are not claimed are considered uninsured and written down to share in the loss to the National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund. Even if shares are uninsured when they are claimed, there may still be a distribution.

On rare occasions, the liquidation of a credit union may result in surplus funds. If a surplus remains, a distribution to the shareholders is required. This may occur several years after the credit union is liquidated and it is sometimes difficult to locate these members.

This is another example where NCUA exempts itself from the rules credit unions are required to follow to protect member’s assets.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 Replies to “A Fee that Credit Unions Should Review for Appropriateness”

  1. Thanks for your blog.

    I like credit unions. I was a member of the Navy Federal Credit Union when I was growing up (courtesy of my father, who was a Marine), and I am currently a happy member of two credit unions– the Harvard University Employees Credit Union, and the Honolulu Federal Credit Union (HOCU). I use both of them fairly often. HOCU has our mortgage.

    Years ago, before joining either of these two, I had an account with the University of Hawaii Federal Credit Union. I put money there as a “rainy day” fund. I didn’t want to use it or think about it, I just wanted to have a reserve for emergencies. I also felt good about putting the money into a credit union, because I thought it would be put to good use in helping others. Unfortunately, when I did not use the account, I was charged for not using it. Eventually, I was locked out of my account, and couldn’t access the account online, because I hadn’t used it. That really ticked me off, so I closed my account. When I closed my account, I explained to the staff that I wanted to just save the money for a rainy day. I couldn’t see how I was costing the credit union by NOT using their services. Meanwhile, they got to use my money. The staff response was that that was their policy. They were sorry. My financial needs conflicted with their policy.

  2. You folks need to quit complaining like a girl jilted on her prom date. A local credit union inactive account fee is a whopper: $5 per month. Yes, after 12 months lapse the credit union treats your inactive account like a damn slot machine collecting $5 a month ($60/year) until it is exhausted, depleted and extinguished. . .

    And because the $5 monthly hit is fully computer automated, the expense to the credit union to wipe out a members meager savings account is next to nothing. Zero, zip, expense. At a local credit union account balances less than $250 earn the goose egg. So here again the credit union has a stack of “free” money earning no dividend, and at the same time extorts $5 a month until it goes away.

    Instead of reducing expenses and creating economies of scale and efficiency most credit unions create new fees while increasing existing fees. Remove fee income from the income statement and many credit unions would report negative income.. . This $5 monthly collection is a business model taken from the MAFIA policies and procedure play book. The MAFIA calls it: juice. Credit Unions call it: fee. Victimized credit union members call it: extortion.

    The end result is a shake down to those that can least afford. Perhaps if the credit union management offered products and services to the membership accounts would not be inactive. Did anyone bother to ask these members why they are inactive? That would require a phone call. It’s far simpler to let the automated computer clip the account at $5 a month. What’s worse is the membership are never notified in advance of the $5 monthly “shake down.” It is buried in a fee disclosure statement.

    Not shocked. Just disappointed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.